ReviewReviewReviewReviewReviewtouching the voidMay 21, '08 12:23 PM
for everyone
Category:Movies
Genre: Documentary
In 1985, Joe Simpson and Simon Yates set out to climb the 21,000 feet Siula Grande mountain in the Peruvian Andes—the only mountain in the Peruvian range that hadn't yet been conquered. They were young, fit, skilled climbers and were confident that they would succeed where others would fail. Their story has become part of mountaineering legend.

Simpson and Yates' method of climbing was Alpine Style—moving quickly up a mountain with the barest of supplies and no series of base camps. This approach left absolutely no room for error. Any problem they might encounter along the way would have extremely grave consequences.

Following a successful three and a half day ascent, disaster struck. Simpson fell and broke several bones in his right leg. His lower leg pushed through his knee joint, crippling him. At that altitude and in those remote conditions, this was effectively a death sentence. With no food or water, severe dehydration and the ugly spectre of hypothermia before them, the climbers knew they had to get off the mountain—and fast. Yates was determined to find a way to get his friend home. They each had 150 feet of rope, which tied together so that Yates could lower Simpson down the mountain 300 feet at a time. The only complication was that Yates had to stop after each 150 feet and signal for Simpson to give him enough slack so that he could get the knot past his harness. Each drop down the mountain was agonizing for Simpson, but Yates had no choice but to ignore his partner's cries. Both of their lives were at stake.

Things were progressing unexpectedly well when Simpson failed to respond to Yates' signal. Unable to move any further and having no idea why Simpson was not pulling at the rope, Yates positioned himself against the mountain face and waited in the blinding storm. He held onto the rope with all of his strength, but was all too aware that eventually his muscles would fail him and both would plummet down the incline. What Yates couldn't know was that he had unknowingly lowered the injured Simpson over the edge of a crevasse. Simpson was hanging over the sheer vertical face of the mountain.

Joe remained suspended, unable to climb back up the rope with frostbitten fingers and unable to communicate with Simon above him. Simon hung onto the rope for an hour, with his strength ebbing away and Joe's weight on the rope slowly pulling him towards the edge of the cliff. Eventually Simon realized he was faced with an unthinkable dilemma: he could hang on to the rope until they were both pulled off the mountain. Logic would say that it would be better for only one man to die rather than both. But the biggest taboo that any climber can commit is to cut the rope that binds you to your partner.

For a climber, it is unthinkable. Certain they would both soon be pulled to their deaths, Yates cut the rope…

seowching wrote on May 21, edited on May 21
During the making of the film, the director and producers invited Simon Yates and Joe Simpson to return to Siula Grande in 2002 for the first time since the events of 1985. Simpson, despite finding the return emotionally difficult and experiencing post traumatic stress syndrome on his return, eventually said that he was happy with the film and its portrayal of the events. Yates, on the other hand, reported having no emotional response to returning to Siula Grande, and decided to have nothing to do with the film once he had returned from the mountain.

After the story of what happened to Simpson and Yates reached home (England), Yates received much criticism from some mountaineers for cutting the rope during the descent. Simpson has deeply accepted that Yates did the right thing and practically saved his life, and has always defended him on that matter.
gintonic77 wrote on May 21
看完啦?喜欢吗?
是一种“情两难,义难全”的挣扎
seowching wrote on May 21
喜欢。还和咸蛋谈论这话题。
seowching wrote on Jun 2
昨晚介紹這部片子給媽媽, 剛開始聽到她嚷著:"很悶啊!"
然後從 joe 斷腿之後, 她就很緊張了 :P
gintonic77 wrote on Jun 2
if she likes " I shouldn't be alive" , then no doubt she will like this too :)
seowching wrote on Jun 2
she just commented that, "i shouldn't be alive" is shorter, 情節比較緊湊, 感覺上比較刺激. :)
gintonic77 wrote on Jun 3
true...but when restricted by time, lots of details are lost
seowching wrote on Jun 4
同意 .
Add a Comment
How would you rate this movie? (optional)
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help